A bad accountant is not just an inconvenience — they can cost your business tens of thousands in SARS penalties, leave you exposed in an audit with incorrect records, or in serious cases, misappropriate funds that take years to recover. The accounting profession in South Africa is partially regulated but has a significant number of practitioners operating without professional membership, without SARS registration, or with qualifications that do not match the services they offer. Knowing the warning signs before you hand over access to your finances is essential protection.
This guide covers the red flags that appear during the hiring process, in the way an accountant manages your work, and in how they respond when things go wrong. Many of these warning signs are subtle — they are not obvious until you know what to look for.
No Professional Membership or Evasive Answers About Qualifications
The first question to ask any prospective accountant is which professional body they belong to and what their membership number is. Reputable South African accounting professionals are registered with SAIPA (South African Institute of Professional Accountants), SAICA (South African Institute of Chartered Accountants), CIMA, or ACCA. Each has a public membership verification system.
Red flags: the accountant cannot produce a membership number; gives a number that does not verify when checked online; claims to be "working towards" registration (which may be true but means they are not yet a registered professional); or deflects the question by talking about experience rather than qualifications. Experience is valuable, but it does not substitute for regulated professional membership when your tax compliance and financial statements are at stake.
Also ask whether they are registered as a Tax Practitioner with SARS. Anyone submitting tax returns on behalf of another person or entity is legally required to be registered with SARS. An unregistered person submitting your returns is not only breaking the law — it means SARS has no professional accountability structure for them and your recourse in a dispute is limited.
Unwillingness to Provide a Written Engagement Letter
A professional accountant will provide a written engagement letter before starting work. This document specifies: which services will be provided, the fees and how they are structured, the submission deadlines the accountant is responsible for, who is responsible for providing source documents by what dates, and what happens if either party needs to terminate the arrangement.
An accountant who resists putting the engagement in writing — who prefers to "keep it flexible" or works on a handshake — is creating conditions where disputes about what was agreed cannot be resolved clearly. This is a significant risk when it comes to who is responsible for a missed SARS submission or an incorrect return. Insist on an engagement letter. A professional accountant will not find this request unusual.
The engagement letter should also confirm what software will be used, who has access to what, and whether you as the client retain administrative access to your own accounting software and SARS eFiling. Any accountant who resists giving you direct access to your own data is creating unhealthy dependency that you should be cautious about.
Missed Deadlines Without Prior Warning
SARS submission deadlines are fixed and the penalties for late filing are real: interest on late tax payments, administrative penalties for late returns, and in serious cases, SARS enforcement action. A professional accountant manages a submissions calendar and communicates with clients well ahead of any deadline.
Red flag: you discover a missed VAT submission from your SARS eFiling portal, not from your accountant. Or a penalty notice arrives and the accountant's explanation is that they forgot, were too busy, or it was your fault for not providing documents on time — without any prior warning that documents were missing.
A professional accountant who needs documents from you will give you advance notice: "Your VAT return is due on the 25th — please send your statements by the 15th." If documents are not received by the agreed date, they will contact you before the deadline, not explain the missed deadline after the fact.
Track your own SARS deadlines independently. Know when your VAT returns (monthly or bi-monthly), PAYE, and income tax returns are due. Check your SARS eFiling profile directly for submission history. This is your business — you should not be entirely dependent on a third party to know what has been submitted on your behalf.
Vague or Unavailable Financial Records
You should be able to access your own financial records at any time. A fundamental red flag is an accountant who cannot produce your records on reasonable request, provides summaries without supporting detail, or claims that records are "on my laptop" and not accessible.
Your accounting data belongs to you. Whether it is stored in Xero, Sage, QuickBooks, or another system, you should have administrative access that does not depend on the accountant's cooperation. If your accountant is the sole user with admin rights to your accounting system, they have created a dependency that gives them unusual leverage — including the ability to walk away with your financial history if the relationship sours.
If your current accountant cannot provide a current trial balance, a list of all transactions for a given period, or access to your software on request, that is not acceptable professional practice. A new accountant taking over from a departing one should have no difficulty obtaining complete records — if your outgoing accountant makes this difficult, it is a signal about why the relationship ended.
Tax Advice That Sounds Too Clever
Tax planning is legitimate — using legal provisions to minimise your tax liability is what a good accountant should do. Tax evasion — structuring transactions to fraudulently reduce your tax liability — is a criminal offence. The line is not always obvious, but some conversations cross it clearly.
Red flags: an accountant who suggests recording personal expenses as business expenses without any genuine business purpose; who recommends paying cash for services to avoid VAT without issuing or retaining invoices; who describes unusual structures as "how everyone does it" without citing the specific SARS provision that allows it; or who is reluctant to put their advice in writing because "these things are better discussed verbally."
If an accountant's tax advice makes you nervous, ask them to send you the written explanation referencing the relevant SARS binding general ruling or Income Tax Act section. A legitimate tax position can be explained and defended in writing. One that cannot should not be acted on.
Poor Communication and Inaccessibility
Your accountant does not need to be on call 24 hours a day, but they should respond to business queries within one to two business days during normal operations. An accountant who is consistently difficult to reach, takes weeks to respond to emails, or is unavailable around submission deadlines is not adequately serving your account.
Red flag during hiring: the accountant is slow to respond during the quoting and proposal phase. If they are slow before they have your business, expect the same or worse once the relationship is established and they are no longer competing for your work.
Quick Checklist Before You Hire
- Ask for their SAIPA or SAICA membership number and verify it online before the first meeting
- Confirm their SARS Tax Practitioner registration number
- Request a written engagement letter — if they resist, look elsewhere
- Ensure you have administrative access to your own accounting software and SARS eFiling
- Track your key SARS deadlines independently — do not rely solely on your accountant's calendar
- Ask for references from at least two current clients of similar size to your business
- If tax advice sounds unusual, ask for the written explanation citing the specific SARS provision
- Note response times during the proposal phase — slow now means slower once they have your account
Verified reviews from other business owners about their accountant are one of the most honest sources of information about how a practitioner actually behaves under pressure — KiesSlim makes it easy to find and read those reviews before you make a decision.